Saturday, January 3, 2015

Review - I'll Have What She's Having: My Adventures in Celebrity Dieting by Rebecca Harrington (COYER Challenge #3)

First, thanks to Edelweiss and Random House Vintage for allowing me to read an e-galley of this title.  It sparked my interest when I first saw it because several years ago I read a bunch of diet type books like this, and really enjoyed them.  This was a very short but sweet read.  And I feel like there could probably have been more added to it, as I think back to the other diet stories I read:  Secrets of a Former Fat GirlHalf-Assed, The Amazing Adventures of Diet Girl, The Incredible Shrinking Critic, and Confessions of a Carb Queen

The humor in which this story was told was as good as any of the others that I read.  I loved how the author seemed to try to have dinner parties with her friends and get them to try to eat what she was eating.  I loved all the observations she had about the people who had the diets that she tried to follow.  One observation that I really loved was with Cameron Diaz's diet.  According to the author, Diaz had always been able to eat whatever she wanted and never gained weight.  But she decided that it wasn't "fair" to her body to keep eating like that.  I agree with the author, Harrington, when she says that "If I was skinny no matter what, I would eat a Burger King Rodeo Burger every day."  For me it wouldn't be the Burger King, but I definitely would eat what I wanted instead of trying to eat some weird diet.

The author tried a total of 14 different celebrity diets according to this book, including not only Cameron Diaz, but also Gwyneth Paltrow, Madonna, Marilyn Monroe, Jackie Kennedy, and Dolly Parton to name a few of them.  If they had an exercise plan also, she mentioned trying some of those.  I don't think she lasted more than a week or two on any of the diets, but she shortened them to fit.  In a way this reminds me not only of the diet memoirs I named in the first paragraph, but also of the books by A.J. Jacobs, like The Guinea Pig Diaries or Drop Dead Healthy

As I said, I wish there had been a bit more to the book.  At one point she off-handedly mentions having a boyfriend, but up until that one point, and nowhere after that point do we hear anything else about this person. I think maybe a bit more personal tidbits, or should I say details about her friends, family, etc, would make it better.  True, these days shorter books that could be considered humor are often popular, but I don't think it would necessarily add that much length to add a bit more detail.  To repeat what I said at the beginning, it was a short, but sweet, as in fun, read.  I do recommend it to anyone, which is everyone, who has ever tried a fad diet, or even wondered what a fad diet might really consist of.

7 comments:

  1. Not heard of this but it sounds interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I just finished this one! I so agree about the wanting more detail. I loved the concept on this one but the execution fell a bit flat for me. Great review!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think they could have done more with it and made it better. But it was an okay read.

      Delete
  3. Hello I'am Chris From France!!
    this is not a "spam"
    You Have A Wonderful Blog Which I Consider To Be Registered In International Blog Dictionary. You Will Represent Your Country
    "Directory Blogspot" is 15 million visitors! .193 Country. 18000 Websites
    Please Visit The Following Link And Comment Your Blog Name
    Blog Url
    Location Of Your Country Operating In Comment Session Which Will Be Added In Your Country List
    On the right side, in the "green list", you will find all the countries and if you click them, you will find the names of blogs from that Country.
    Imperative to follow our blog to validate your registration.Thank you for your understanding
    http://world-directory-sweetmelody.blogspot.com/
    Happy Blogging
    ****************
    Bonne Année ! Happy New Year! Feliz Año Nuevo! Buon Anno! Feliz Ano Novo! Glückliches Neues Jahr!
    for you and your entire family.
    A small gift for you
    **********************
    http://nsm08.casimages.com/img/2014/12/25//14122507483612502812823262.gif
    ******************

    ReplyDelete
  4. This definitely sounds like it could be a fun read! I so agree that if I could eat whatever I wanted and not gain weight, I wouldn't worry much. I mean, throw some vegetables and fruit in when I felt like it, but fried chickennnnn, too. :) I bet I'd want more details about her life, too, though, since it makes her experiences feel more real and less like fodder for the book, I guess? :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fried chicken, especially chicken tenders, is my biggest weakness. With ranch dressing to dip it in. And Queso dip at Mexican restaurants. And wedding cake!!! Now I'm hungry.

      Delete

I love to get comments and I read them all! If you leave a link in your comment, I just might visit you back.