Review: The Fever by Megan Abbott

This is one I was lucky enough to get an ARC of at BEA this summer, along with an autograph.  It was one I wanted for sure, the little synopsis sounded good.  But I guess I only read the first sentence or two of that, because I didn't realize that it was about the same incident that a book I finished reading a little while ago, Conversion, talked about.   Again, I remember the story of the girls who were all of a sudden coming down with tics and other ailments for seemingly no reason, out of nowhere.  While Conversion kind of went with a tie to the Salem witch trials, this book was different.

The main character is really Deenie.  All of the problems begin when her friend Lise collapses in the middle of class and begins having a seizure.  Unfortunately in this day and age of the cell phone, other students take pictures of her in this situation, and many aren't flattering.  She goes home, has another seizure, which leads to a cardiac event of some sort, and she falls and hits her head on a coffee table.  She is taken back to the hospital, where soon she is just unconscious, basically in a coma.  Her mother begins trying to figure out what is the cause.  And not long after this, Deenie's other best friend, Gabby, also seems to have a seizure, at school, in the middle of an orchestra concert.  Hers doesn't seem to be quite as bad.  But now all the parents are up in arms, trying to figure out what is going on.  One thing that is jumped on is the HPV vaccine that the school had begun making all girls get, or getting a note to get out of it.  But then another girl gets sick, and it turns out that she didn't have the vaccination.  So talk in the town turns to the really gross polluted lake nearby.  And of course there is even some talk about girls getting sexually active too soon. Which the girls do talk about in this book. 

We also get part of the story from Deenie's father, Tom's point of view.  He is a teacher at the school, so it is definitely good to get both a parent, as well as a staff member at the school's take on what is happening.  As a science teacher, he is able to be rational about what the cause might be even.

We also get some bits from the point of view of Deenie's brother Eli.  Eli seems to be a bit of a womanizer.  And I don't know that I really am a huge fan of his from how the book portrays him.  I can't quite figure out what is going on with him.  I think that the author is trying to show how confusing it might be for a boy that age to have girls throwing themselves at him, all the time thinking about how he would feel if his sister did those things, and if boys treated her the way he treated some girls so casually.

Definitely a different take than Conversion, and the story is told in a way I got to know the characters better than I felt I did in Conversion.  But both have their own good parts.  So I think it could be something to have students read both books and compare, then look at maybe newspaper articles of the actual events these are kind of based on. 

Me with Megan Abbott

Review: Conversion by Katherine Howe

First, thanks to Edelweiss and Putnam Juvenile for allowing me to read an e-galley of this title.  I have read the adult novel by this same author, The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane, and it was also very interesting.  I don't think I have that review on this blog that I can link back to unfortunately though.  When I heard the way they were promoting this, Prep meets The Crucible, I must say I was very intrigued and so requested it.

Now, I don't know if that description is actually right on the money.  Yes, we have a prep school, all girls.  And yes, it is talking about the exact story of The Crucible.  But it was still a pretty good story the way it was.  We had flashbacks from the time of the Salem witch trials.  And we also had up to date parts of the story of a group of girls who began developing little tics and other types of illnesses seemingly for no reason, and with no causes.  The main character, at least in the modern part of the story, is named Colleen.  She is actually reading The Crucible, something that the students should have already read, but now she is reading it for extra credit because she really wants to be the valedictorian for her class.  She finds many similarities between the girls from back during the witch trials and what is happening to the girls in her class.  She even discovers some things that didn't even occur to me until they were pointed out in the book.

Some things that disappointed me were I would have liked more information about the modern day girls.  As well as more information from other viewpoints of the girls back in the original witch trials in the book.

Another reason I had been really intrigued to read this is because I remember when the girls were coming on the news and claiming all these weird tics and things happening to them.  I don't remember hearing much about it since.  I'm assuming that maybe the true story ended up with the same kind of diagnosis as the book did.  I'll have to do some research into that myself some time.  Definitely a good book for students to read who are interested in the Salem Witch Trials.  Could definitely be a good read after or with The Crucible.  I will be putting this on my list to order for the high school library where I work.

On a personal note, my recovery from my surgery last week seems to be going pretty well.  Unfortunately I've not read as much as I'd like so far, because a lot of times I'm still kind of tired and go to sleep instead of reading.  But I'm getting better slowly, so reading and blogging will get back on track!!